
The Pittsburgh Steelers gifted the Washington Commanders with incredible field position on the greatest fake punt of all-time that didn’t work. Yes, you read that sentence correctly.
Mike Tomlin dialed up a trick play during the first half that looked for a moment like it was going to go for six… until it didn’t.
Punter Corliss Waitman lined up with his back against the goal line on 4th-and-15 during the first quarter. Pittsburgh was already up 7-0. However, he did not kick the ball away!
Safety Miles Killebrew intercepted the snap from the personal protector position and immediately looked to pass. Washington’s return team never saw it coming.
Defensive back James Pierre was split out wide to the left as a gunner. The Commanders, which brought pressure to try and block the punt, did not mark him. He was out there all by himself.

Unfortunately, the old adage applies and there is a reason Pierre plays corner and not receiver— his hands. Or, rather, a lack thereof.
Killebrew fired a high-arcing pass out to the edge before Washington’s rush could penetrate into the backfield. It was wide open. If Pierre caught the pass and turned up field, he would’ve had just one man to beat down the sideline.
He could not make the catch. He dropped it.
Fake punt pass dropped uh oh #Steelers pic.twitter.com/oQn0FnS23z
— Steelers Depot 7⃣ (@Steelersdepot) November 10, 2024
Noah Igbinoghene was in hot pursuit of Pierre while he tried to haul in the pass but it seemed as though the latter had plenty of time to make the catch for the first down, turn up field and potentially score. And then he dropped it.
Steelers try a fake punt from their 16 yard line.
— Armando Salguero (@ArmandoSalguero) November 10, 2024
It was there!
And then it wasn’t. pic.twitter.com/OYzeOFbvoR
Waitman thought for sure the fake was going to work and celebrated as such for a moment. His reaction to the drop speaks louder than words.
Could James Pierre get cut for this?
— Obviously (Not) Tomlin (@Tomlin_Sense) November 10, 2024
I wouldn’t urinate on that fire.#Steelers #HereWeGo pic.twitter.com/OZ5J29uZPW
Not only did the Steelers fail to move the chains because of James Pierre’s drop, the Commanders took over at the 16. It was the best fake punt in NFL history that didn’t work.