A Rare Baseball Card Sold For More Than $1 Million At Auction And It Wasn’t Even In Good Shape

baseball field

iStockphoto / Alex Gombash

The high-end sports memorabilia industry is something I’ll never be able to wrap my mind around. Despite not having the cash to buy these things for myself, I can understand spending hundreds of thousands of dollars (millions??) on art, watches, jewelry, cars, and wine.

I cannot, for the life of me, understand why anyone would spend seven figures on the baseball card of a man who was probably deceased before they were even born, the card of a baseball player who is really only best known because of how rare and famous the baseball card is.

I’m talking about the baseball card of Johannes Peter “Honus” Wagner. He played 21 seasons from 1897 to 1917. Don’t get me wrong, Honus Wagner was a stud on the field. He was an 8x NL Batting Champion and 5x RBI + Stolen Bases leader in the NL. He won the World Series in 1909. But this was a time when the game was VERY different than it was today. Dudes were smoking cigarettes on the field and drinking beers in the dugout.

Only 56 copies of the T206 Honus Wagner baseball card are known to exist in the world making it one of the rarest items in baseball memorabilia and one of the most expensive baseball cards in the world. The American Tobacco Company (ATC) made distributed somewhere between 57 to 200 of these T206 Honus Wagner baseball cards between 1909 to 1911 as part of its T206 series. According to Wiki, the other cards in the T206 series had thousands of prints whereas the Honus Wagner was limited to extremely limited production.

One of these 110-year-old baseball cards was sold at auction by SCP Auctions in SoCal. The condition of this card was rated 2 out of 10. FAR FROM MINT CONDITION. In fact, I’d go as far as saying that’s pretty in shitty condition. This card still sold for an asinine amount of money.

This beat up ‘2 out of 10’ condition Honus Wagner T206 baseball card. A piece of paper with a dead man’s picture on it, just sold for $1,200,000 at auction.

$1.2 MILLION for that.

If we’re being honest, I don’t really see that as being in ‘2 out of 10 condition’ but I’m not a collector or an appraiser and I never will be so I’ll leave those assessments up to people with a trained eye.

I guess upon closer inspection you can see some scratches and damage to the card:

I repeat, $1.2 MILLION for that. For a baseball card. A tiny piece of paper with a dead man’s picture on it and some words.

I could be insane for thinking this but I’ve always had a hunch that the sports memorabilia industry will collapse in our lifetime. In most sports, I see a bigger market for memorabilia from current athletes (Tiger Woods, LeBron James, etc) than retired athletes. Is a millennial ever going to spend $2 million on some Babe Ruth autographed stuff? NOPE.

For more on this auction, you can click here to visit the SCP Auctions website.