Week 18 NFL Grades: Grading Every Team’s Week 18 Sunday Performance

The final Sunday of the NFL season is in the books. Here is how each team graded out on Sunday.

We did it, folks. The NFL Regular Season is complete, and the final Sunday of the season was full of surprises. Here is how each team that played on Sunday graded out in the season’s final week.

As always, these grades don’t just take into account how a team played and the final score. It factors in things like expectations, short and long-term goals of the franchise, injuries, and other factors. This late in the year, draft position will play a huge role in grades.The big picture has to be kept in mind.

Carolina Panthers: A+

44-38 (W) @ Falcons

Yes, it cost the Panthers a few spots in draft position. But, for a team that has drastically improved as the season went on, this is the perfect way to end the season. Bryce Young was fantastic, Dave Canales coached a marvelous game, and the Panthers enter the offseason a much-improved team with some real momentum. This is the best Panthers fans have felt in years.

Atlanta Falcons: F

44-38 (L) Vs. Panthers

It ultimately ended up not mattering due to Tampa Bay’s come-from-behind win. But, this was a team that needed to win on Sunday to have any chance of advancing in the postseason. They didn’t play like it, especially on defense. Giving up 38 points to the Panthers at home is an effort that didn’t deserve the playoffs. And, while Michael Penix Jr. played well, Sunday’s loss cemented the season as a failure.

Washington Commanders: A+

23-19 (W) @ Cowboys

Not only did the Commanders get out of Dallas with a win on Sunday while resting many of its starters for much of the game, but it also clinched a better postseason draw, as they will play the Tampa Bay Buccaneers in the Wild Card Round instead of the Philadelphia Eagles.

Dallas Cowboys: C+

23-19 (L) Vs. Commanders

The Cowboys played hard, but came up short. So, why the solid grade? Trey Lance made his first start for the team and looked like a viable backup for next season, and they improved their draft position, as they will pick 12th. Finally, a disaster season in Dallas is finally over.

Chicago Bears: B-

24-22 (W) Vs. Packers

Yes, their draft position slipped a bit, so they get a bit off the grade. But, they finally got a win over Green Bay for the first time since 2018. And, while it ended up not mattering, it was a game that Green Bay was indeed trying to win. After a nine-game losing streak, the vibes will be improved heading into the offseason by just a little bit.

Green Bay Packers: D-

24-22 (L) @ Bears

The Packers looked to avoid serious injury to Jordan Love and the game ultimately ended up not mattering. But, this was a game they needed to win if they had any hopes of avoiding the Eagles in the Wild Card Round. Instead, they lost to a Bears team that quit on its season long ago. The Packers will limp into the playoffs as losers of 3 of 5 and 2 straight games.

Houston Texans: A

23-14 (W) @ Titans

It’s not a *strong* A, because there isn’t much to glen from it. But, they got out of it what they wanted, which is a win, health, and a good appearance for CJ Stroud. Maybe this helps them build some momentum heading into the playoffs after stumbling down the stretch.

Tennessee Titans: A

23-14 (L) Vs. Texans

There’s not much to say but this: Tennessee, you are on the clock. The Titans’ loss and the Patriots win means that they will pick number-one overall for the first time ever in Tennessee, and the first time as a franchise since 1978, when they took Earl Campbell.

Jacksonville Jaguars: B

26-23 (L) @ Colts

A miserable season for the Jaguars comes to an end, and a clutch loss in overtime preserves the fifth-overall pick. Brian Thomas and Travon Walker continued to shine, too.

Indianapolis Colts: C

26-23 (W) Vs. Jaguars

They won, but this grade takes a hit because they can’t quite wash off the stink of last week’s dismal loss to the Giants. And, why are they giving Jonathan Taylor 34 carries in a meaningless game? That’s ridiculous coaching and management. The team will bring back GM Chris Ballard and Head Coach Shane Steichen next year.

Buffalo Bills: B+

23-16 (L) @ Patriots

The Bills suffered no meaningful injuries, and that’s all that mattered on Sunday.

New England Patriots: B+

23-16 (W) Vs. Bills

The Patriots lost the number-one overall pick on Sunday with a win, which is a huge step backwards for the franchise. They would’ve gotten a huge haul of assets when they traded away the pick to a quarterback-needy team. But, the players and coaches don’t try to lose, and rookie backup Joe Milton played a great game. He could be worth something on the trade market.

So, why the B+? Robert Kraft fired Jerod Mayo, who was way over his head as a head coach. Despite losing the first-overall pick, Sunday was a positive day in New England.

New York Giants: B

20-13 (L) @ Eagles

One week after costing itself the number-one pick with a win over the Colts, the Giants did no further damage this week. And, Malik Nabers continues to look a franchise player. Overall, a good day.

Philadelphia Eagles: A

20-13 (W) Vs. Giants

They rested the studs and won anyways. It couldn’t have gone much better from a Philadelphia perspective.

New Orleans Saints: B

27-19 (L) @ Buccaneers

The Saints get a good grade for playing hard for interim head coach Darren Rizzi while Spencer Rattler played well. And, they preserved their draft position. A huge rebuild should commence.

Tampa Bay Buccaneers: A+

27-19 (W) Vs. Saints

It wasn’t pretty, but the Buccaneers won and clinched a playoff spot. That’s what mattered on Sunday, and they got it done.

Los Angeles Chargers: A+

34-20 (W) @ Raiders

Things worked out perfectly for the Chargers this weekend, as a Pittsburgh loss and their win gave them the fifth-seed in the AFC. That means a date with a struggling Texans squad. Most importantly, a surging passing game continued to improve, and Quentin Johnston and Justin Herbert looked to really develop a rapport. The Chargers are very dangerous this postseason.

Las Vegas Raiders: C

34-20 (L) Vs. Chargers

The Raiders preserved their draft position at number-six, which is one of the few positives you can take from this season. Hopefully, they don’t move up for a quarterback in the NFL Draft and give Aidan O’Connell a full year as a starter

Seattle Seahawks: B

30-25 (W) @ Rams

The Seahawks finish off a 10-7 season on a high note. In fact, this team went 7-1 on the road, and still missed the playoffs. Yes, 10-7 is going to get you in most of the time, but that’s still a crazy stat.

Los Angeles Rams: D-

30-25 (L) Vs. Seahawks

Had the Rams won on Sunday, they would’ve avoided the 14-3 Vikings in the Wild Card Round and played a very beatable Commanders team. Instead, they rested starters. I truly do not get it, and it might come back to bite them next weekend.

Miami Dolphins: F

32-20 (L) Vs. Jets

It ended up not mattering, but it was a game they needed to win, and fell well short of doing so. And, after the game, Tyreek Hill made it clear that he wants out of Miami. Overall, a really bad day at the office for this franchise.

New York Jets: D

32-20 (W)

Aaron Rodgers played one of his best games of the season, and it cost the Jets draft position. That sums up a disastrous New York Jets season.

San Francisco 49ers: D

47-24 (L) @ Cardinals

Why the low grade in a game that meant nothing and cemented better draft position? It was yet another exhibit in support of the fact that window on this core has closed. That’s a sobering thought for any 49ers fan.

Arizona Cardinals: B+

47-24 (W) Vs. 49ers

The Cardinals played themselves out of the playoffs down the stretch, so this was a big win to feel good about itself heading into the offseason. Ultimately, eight wins out of this roster isn’t so bad.

Kansas City Chiefs: Incomplete

38-0 (L) @ Broncos

If the NFL would’ve let the Chiefs just forfeit the game and not fly to Denver, they would have.

Denver Broncos

Minnesota Vikings: D-

31-9 (L) @ Detroit

The only positive in a blowout loss that is the difference between home-field advantage throughout the playoffs and traveling to Los Angeles next week is that they seemingly avoided major injuries. That’s the only positive.

Detroit Lions: A+

31-9 (W) Vs. Vikings

The NFC will run through Detroit after a dominant second half in the NFL’s biggest regular season game maybe ever. How about that maligned Detroit defense that kept the Vikings out of the end zone? Once again, the Lions are the favorites to win their first-ever Super Bowl.

Garrett Carr BroBible avatar
Garrett Carr is an editor at BroBible with an expertise in NFL and other major professional sports. He is a graduate of Penn State University and resides in Pennsylvania. Garrett is a diehard Penn State, New York Mets, and New York Knicks fan.
Want more news like this? Add BroBible as a preferred source on Google!
Preferred sources are prioritized in Top Stories, ensuring you never miss any of our editorial team's hard work.
Google News Add as preferred source on Google