
iStockphoto
A suspicious video of Mary Star High School football players is raising questions.
Mary Star of the Sea High School in San Pedro, California is entwined in an unexpected drama involving potentially illegal football players. A suspicious video has raised eligibility questions amid a playoff run.
The head coach of the program has responded to the claims as he preps for his next contest. He adamantly refutes having violated any recruiting or residence policies.
The California Interscholastic Federation, the state’s governing body for high school sports, is aware of the video being circulated. To this point, no wrongdoing has been proven.
Mary Star High School is on a ridiculous run.
The Stars went 9-1 during the regular season to earn a top playoff seed. That comes after a 10-win season in 2024 and an eight-win campaign last year.
Head coach Tyler Sestich took over ahead of that ’24 season. He became the program’s fourth leader in as many years.
In the three years prior to his arrival, the Stars went a combined 11-19. Since Sestich’s arrival, Mary Star is 28-7. They earned a first-round bye in this year’s playoffs before beating Muir on the final play in the quarterfinals to advance. The Stars are now one win away from a championship game appearance.
Mary Star wins on final play of the game Ian Ditch hits Seth Guevara with a 6 yd TD pass as time expires 27-26 Stars advance. @breezepreps @MaryStarfball https://t.co/IasSc3CEwZ
— @ricebites (@calfladave22) November 14, 2026
Sestich cares deeply about the health of the program. He was raised in San Pedro. He’s an alum, as are many on his staff. Success is a badge of honor, not only as a coach but as a former student and player.
But while those affiliated with the school have been ecstatic with the team’s quick rise, the turnaround has created questions for rivals.
How did Mary Star football get so good, so quickly?
Whispers of potential rule breaking in terms of player recruitment and eligibility have circulated. This week, a suspicious video stoked the fire.
California high school football video raises questions.
Someone drove to this residence and secretly recorded a bunch of Mary Star HS football players leaving one house.😂😂😂 Yal be careful; they out here hating. Maybe it was a sleepover 🙃 https://t.co/uZ8kT5Osbm
— Dame Lester (@1Dame) November 17, 2026
Someone recorded multiple Mary Star of the Sea football players leaving the same residence one morning for school. It creates speculation related to player eligibility.
Are they living at the same address? Is it a violation of the CIF residence policy?
Other California high school football Southern Section members have been busted in recent years for breaking these rules.
Last year, there was a major crackdown on transfer students. Norco High School was barred from the playoffs for the use of an ineligible player. Orange Lutheran forfeited contests for the same reason. Bishop Montgomery fired their coach after the discovery of falsified residency paperwork and a connection to a rogue booster’s illegal recruitment.
Those are just a few.
Earlier this year, parents of Westlake High School football players voiced concerns over an alleged recruiting scandal related to transfer athletes. It’s a hot topic.
The video of Mary Star players leaving the same home has now put the Stars under the spotlight. Has rule breaking occurred?
Tyler Sestich responds to the rumors.
Tarek Fattal of Sports Illustrated obtained the video in question. He spoke to the California high school football coach about a possible violation.
Sestich denies wrongdoing. The school provided a statement on the situation ahead of its next playoff game.
“Student athletes depicted in the video reside at their home-stay residence. These students are international students that were approved by the Department of Catholic Schools. They live with a home-stay family which includes a father and a mother of a Mary Star student and his younger brother.”
Sestich also delivered a direct response to Fattal’s video on social media. He laughed off the accusations with a sarcastic message that supports the school’s statement.
@Tarek_Fattal @ChemicalAT Can’t wait to watch the breaking video of some international students leaving their host family house to go to mass in the morning 😂😂
— Coach Tyler Sestich (@tylersestich) November 16, 2026
The players are international students, according to Mary Star of the Sea High School. They have been approved to attend the school and play for the football team.
The statement does not answer questions on the motivation for choosing the school. Why did they pick Mary Star ahead of a more notable program in the area?
Fattal and his co-host suggest that these are major contributors for the Stars, but while the video does raise concerns, it does not prove rule breaking.
Sestich denies wrongdoing. His program has done things by the books. He claims that the players are approved and eligible for play. They’ll expect to suit up for the upcoming playoff bout with Aquinas on Friday.