Cleveland Guardians Pitchers’ Gambling Trial Gets Weirder With $19K In Winning Bets And Talk Of Cockfighting

luis-ortiz
Brian Bradshaw Sevald-Imagn Images

The gambling fraud trial involving Cleveland Guardians pitchers Emmanuel Clase and Luis Ortiz just keeps getting stranger.

On Monday, a FanDuel executive testified that gamblers made more than $19,000 in profits betting on a single pitch thrown by Luis Ortiz. Meanwhile, attorneys are still arguing over whether text messages about chickens referred to cockfighting or secretly rigging baseball games.

According to The Athletic, FanDuel executive Josh Mehta testified that six bets were placed on Ortiz throwing a ball on the first pitch of the third inning against the St. Louis Cardinals on June 27, 2025.

Luis Ortiz threw a low-and-away slider to catcher Pedro Pages. It was a ball.

The next day, FanDuel suspended four accounts that had bet on that pitch and another Ortiz pitch on June 15. Then, Ortiz was placed on administrative leave on July 3. Emmanuel Clase followed Ortiz on July 28.

Gambling Trial Includes Some Bizarre Text Messages About Chickens

As previously reported, prosecutors accuse Emmanuel Clase and Luis Ortiz of deliberately manipulating pitches to help gamblers win hundreds of thousands of dollars.

Federal prosecutors have identified 18 pitches they believe Clase rigged. Ortiz is accused of rigging two. Both pitchers have pleaded not guilty.

One unusual aspect of the trial involves text messages in which Clase discusses chickens. Prosecutors claim the messages were actually coded instructions about which pitches gamblers should bet on.

Cleveland-Guardians-relief-pitcher-Emmanuel-Clase-throws-a-pitch
Brad Mills-Imagn Images

In one message from September 2023, Emmanuel Clase allegedly wrote, “It’s chicken number three. After killing the first two, play number three.”

His attorneys, however, insist he was talking about actual cockfighting, which is legal in his native Dominican Republic. They even presented videos of roosters in cages that Clase had shared.

“I like to fight my birds where the real cockfights are,” Clase wrote in another message.

Defense attorneys also suggested the payments could have been related to cockfighting rather than rigged baseball pitches.

Witness Claims He Never Discussed Gambling With Emmanuel Clase

One witness, Jenner Olivo, testified Monday that he sent three payments totaling $5,500 to a man in the Dominican Republic at the direction of Enoc Pena, the alleged middleman in the gambling scheme.

“He’s a person that gambles constantly,” Jenner Olivo said of Pena.

However, under cross-examination, Olivo admitted he never directly discussed betting with Emmanuel Clase.

Prosecutors hope to wrap up their case by Friday.

Douglas Charles headshot avatar BroBible
Douglas Charles is a Senior Editor for BroBible with two decades of expertise writing about sports, science, and pop culture with a particular focus on the weird news and events that capture the internet's attention. He is a graduate from the University of Iowa.
Want more news like this? Add BroBible as a preferred source on Google!
Preferred sources are prioritized in Top Stories, ensuring you never miss any of our editorial team's hard work.
Google News Add as preferred source on Google