Jeremiah Smith Earned The Heisman Trophy By Faking A Leg Injury To Avoid Costly Penalty In Crucial Situation

Jeremiah Smith fake injury cramp penalty timeout IQ heisman trophy ohio state
CFB on FOX

Jeremiah Smith is the betting favorite to win the Heisman Trophy. He saved Ohio State from a costly penalty with a fake injury.

It was his best play of the game!

Even though Smith continues to be the most athletic player in college football, his IQ is what sets him apart. The 20-year-old is more than just a freak of nature.

Jeremiah Smith is the best player in college football.

Buckeyes pass-catcher Jeremiah Smith has -142 odds to win the Heisman Trophy. Miami quarterback Darian Mensah is listed at +370. Utah quarterback Devon Dampier is listed at +550. Everybody else is listed at +1000 or greater.

Barring a miraculous end-of-season performance by Mensah and/or Dampier, or a disastrous end-of-season performance by Smith, it seems like a true wide receiver is going to win the Heisman Trophy for just the second time since 1991. Travis Hunter won in 2024 as a two-way superstar and DeVonta Smith won in 2020.

Smith, a junior, entered the weekend with the second-most receiving yards (less than 35 yards behind Oregon State’s Jesse Legree), the second-most catches, and the most receiving touchdowns in the country. He had 80 catches for 1,317 yards and 15 touchdowns through the first 10 games of the regular season.

It did not take long for him to get going against Nebraska on Saturday!

Smith finished the first half with four catches for 117 yards and two touchdowns to jump into the lead in every receiving category. His first touchdown catch went for 67 yards on the sixth play of the game.

And then he did this before halftime:

That catch should probably seal the deal. Even if Ohio State finishes with four or five losses, its star wide receiver continues to do things that nobody else is doing.

A fake injury saved Ohio State from a costly penalty.

Although Jeremiah Smith is best known for his freakish athleticism, it was his situational awareness that actually proved to be most valuable on Saturday. Even if it was questionable gamesmanship…

Ohio State had the ball on offense with just over three minutes remaining in the second quarter. It faced 3rd-and-6 at its own 47-yard-line while trailing 21-7.

Right as the Buckeyes went to break the huddle, Smith realized there were 12 men on the field and immediately went down with a fake cramp. The fake injury allowed the offense to avoid a penalty for breaking the huddle with too many players on the field.

The NCAA enacted a rule to penalize suspected fake injuries in 2025. Ohio State was forced to take a timeout because Smith went down after the ball was spotted for the next play. However, it was not flagged for breaking the huddle with more than 11 players and did not lose five yards.

A head coach would much rather take a timeout than a loss of five yards on third down. Smith proved that he deserves the Heisman Trophy by faking a leg cramp!