Tennessee College Volleyball Team Lost Its Conference Championship Game On Major Controversy From Rogue Buzzer

Lee University women's college volleyball controversy montevallo buzzer replay gulf south conference championship
Hailey Simco / Lee University Athletics

Lee University lost to the University of Montevallo in the Gulf South Conference championship game for women’s college volleyball. However, the Flames believe the head official made an error on what would’ve been the deciding point of the match.

He called for a stoppage, and a replay of the point, because of an inadvertent buzzer.

The replayed point flipped the women’s college volleyball match on its head. It resulted in a major controversy.

Lee lost to Montevallo in the Gulf South Conference championship.

Lee University is a private Christian university located in Cleveland, Tennessee. Founded in 1918 with twelve students and one teacher, it currently enrolls more than 3,800 students in total with ~3,400 undergraduates. The Flames compete in 20 intercollegiate varsity sports on the NCAA Division II level in the Gulf South Conference. That includes women’s volleyball.

The University of Montevallo is the only public liberal arts college in Alabama. Established in 1986, it currently enrolls more than 3,000 students in total with ~2,600 undergraduates. The Falcons compete in 18 intercollegiate varsity sports. They are also members of the Gulf South Conference on the NCAA Division II level.

Lee’s women’s volleyball team finished the regular season at 16-10. Montevallo finished at 20-9. The former earned the No. 4 seed in the Gulf South Conference tournament. The latter earned the No. 3 seed.

They met in the conference championship game over the weekend. It was a five-set thriller.

The Flames lost sets one and two by a score of 27-25. They rallied back to win sets three and four by scores of 25-19 and 25-21. The fifth set went long. The Falcons ultimately won the fifth set 16-14 to win the match.

Lee finished with seven more kills, four more assists, 13 more digs and 16 more blocks. Montevallo won the conference.

However, the match did not come without controversy. The final four three points of the game were played under protest.

The women’s college volleyball referee called for a replay because of a buzzer.

Lee took a 14-13 lead over Montevallo in the fifth and final set. After a timeout, sophomore setter Sydney Sharpe went back to the line to serve for the Flames. She sent the ball over the net. The ball was touched by a Falcons player.

As a second player dove for the ball to try and keep the match alive, a random buzzer sounded. It was not related to the match.

Meanwhile, the ball hit the floor. Lee won the fifth set 15-13 to win the match and the Gulf South Conference. Players stormed on to the court to celebrate. They thought the match was over.

It wasn’t! The up ref decided to replay the point because of the inadvertent buzzer.

Montevallo rallied for three-straight points to win the fifth set 16-14 and the match. The Falcons were officially crowned as conference champions but the Flames are not going down with a fight. They released the following statement:

“We are incredibly proud of our volleyball student-athletes and coaches and the way they represented Lee throughout the Gulf South Conference Championship. Their performance today reflected the character, preparation, and competitive excellence they have demonstrated all season. We congratulate the University of Montevallo on a well played match, and appreciate all efforts that went into hosting the Gulf South Conference Championship.

“At the same time, we are deeply disappointed by the circumstances surrounding the conclusion of today’s championship match. We believe the deciding call was incorrect and took an earned championship away from our team. Our student-athletes won on the court, and deserved better from the lead official in that moment.

“When an error of this significance occurs, accountability matters. Our players and coaches are owed an acknowledgment of what happened and an apology from the Gulf South Conference and the officiating crew. We will communicate our concerns directly through the appropriate conference channels and expect them to be taken seriously.

“Nothing about the way this match ended diminishes what this team accomplished. We are tremendously proud of our student-athletes, our coaches, and the way they represented Lee University.”

Maybe the Gulf South Conference will declare Lee as co-champions. It is not going to revoke the win from Montevallo.