7 NFL Players Who Could Have Gone Pro In A Different Sport

Antonio Gates, Tom Brady, and Kyler Murray

Doug Pensinger/Getty Images/Raj Mehta-USA TODAY Sports/USA TODAY Network via Reuters Connect

Antonio Gates, Tom Brady, and Kyler Murray


Going pro in one sport is impressive enough, but some athletes are talented to the point where they had multiple options to pick from when it came to pursuing a pastime for a living. That includes some NFL players who made a name for themselves on the gridiron but could have done the same in another realm.

These Are 7 NFL Players Who Could Have Gone Pro In A Different Sport

Some NFL players have actually managed to play two sports at the highest level, either simultaneously or one before the other. We won’t include them, but standouts include Bo Jackson, Deion Sanders, and Brandon Weeden, the last of whom played five seasons of professional baseball before becoming a QB.

The harsh reality is most of these guys landed in football because it was their best option. Being a professional basketball or baseball player typically pays more and doesn’t come with the same physical toll.

Nonetheless, these guys came extremely close to becoming pro athletes in a completely different sport, which is insanely impressive.

Kyler Murray

Vikings QB Kyler Murray

Brad Rempel-Imagn Images


Kyler Murray leads off this list because he is the only athlete in history to be drafted in the top ten of multiple sports. Murray was drafted ninth overall by the Athletics in the 2018 MLB Draft, then went on to be selected with the first overall pick in the 2019 NFL Draft.

This led to an interesting conversation around Murray because he had a significant amount of money on the table in baseball, but at the time he was the highest-rated NFL prospect on the board.

After being taken first, the choice became clear, and Murray hasn’t picked up a baseball bat since college.

Antonio Gates

Chargers TE Antonio Gates

Kirby Lee-Imagn Images


I spoke about Antonio Gates in my article about overlooked high school recruits, but he applies here as well.

Gates initially wanted to play both basketball and football at Michigan State, but head coach Nick Saban decided he would only play football if he came to Lansing. Gates ultimately chose basketball and played four years as a power forward for Kent State.

But as the draft process neared, he wasn’t getting the attention he wanted despite averaging 20 PPG as a senior. He then decided to give football another shot, worked out for a few teams, and signed with the San Diego Chargers as an undrafted free agent.

Jameis Winston

Jameis Winston starting for the New York Giants

© Yannick Peterhans / USA TODAY NETWORK via Imagn Images


When people think of Jameis Winston these days, they remember his funny personality and tendency to throw interceptions (like the 30 he tossed in 2019)

But he was an elite athlete coming out of Alabama and actually played both baseball and football at Florida State. Winston was a pitcher, right fielder, and DH on the diamond and got selected in the 15th round of the 2012 MLB Draft by the Rangers.

But after two prolific football seasons, the 6’4, 230-lb QB decided football was his better option and went first overall in the 2015 NFL Draft.

Russell Wilson

Russell Wilson / Seattle Seahawks

© Kirby Lee-Imagn Images


Russell Wilson was drafted three times in his athletic career, twice in baseball (by the Orioles in 2007 and the Rockies in 2010) and once in football (2012).

After briefly pursuing baseball, he missed spring football at NC State due to minor-league spring training. This caused a rift with the program, and the QB was forced to transfer in 2011.

Ironically, he then committed to football full time and played one season at Wisconsin before being selected in the third round of the 2012 NFL draft.

John Elway

Broncos QB John Elway

Imagn Images


John Elway had a real shot at playing in the MLB at one point. He was selected in the second round of the 1981 MLB Draft by the Yankees, two years after the Royals scooped him up in the 18th round. He declined to ink a deal with Kansas City, but he earned a $140,000 bonus for signing with the Bronx Bombers (like Wilson) and played in the minors while still a college QB.

In the minors, he batted .318 with four home runs after being taken six picks ahead of Hall of Famer Tony Gwynn.

He was taken first overall in the 1983 NFL draft by the Baltimore Colts, but had no interest in playing for them and chose baseball. It wasn’t until the Denver Broncos traded for Elway that his Hall of Fame football career began.

Patrick Mahomes

Kansas-City-Chiefs-quarterback-Patrick-Mahomes

Mark J. Rebilas-Imagn Images


Patrick Mahomes was destined to be a pro athlete since the day he was born, but most people would’ve guessed he would go to MLB.

Pat Mahomes’ dad played 11 years in the big leagues as a pitcher and passed his talents onto his son. His son was drafted by the Tigers in the 37th round of the 2014 MLB draft, but he decided to play baseball and football at Texas Tech.

But shortly after, Mahomes decided to focus on football, and clearly, it was the right call.

Tom Brady

Tom Brady on the Tampa Bay Buccaneers

Kim Klement-USA TODAY Sports


Mahomes wasn’t the only elite QB who almost played baseball, as the man who is arguably the G.OA.T. could also hold his own on the diamond; Tom Brady was also essentially the quarterback of his team as a catcher at Junípero Serra High School.

He was good enough to be selected by the Montreal Expos in the 18th round of the 1995 MLB draft, but unfortunately for virtually every team he played against, Brady declined a professional baseball career and played only college football at the University of Michigan before embarking on one fo the most legendary NFL careers of all time.

BroBible author Billy Niles avatar
Billy Niles is originally from Connecticut but lives in Dallas after graduating from TCU. He devotes a good chunk of his free time to playing golf and bar trivia, and is a big fan of Boston and TCU sports while also following tennis, golf, and UFC
Want more news like this? Add BroBible as a preferred source on Google!
Preferred sources are prioritized in Top Stories, ensuring you never miss any of our editorial team's hard work.
Google News Add as preferred source on Google