iStockphoto
Maury beat Lake Taylor 96-14 in Virginia high school football action.
Maury High School in Norfolk, Virginia beat region rival Lake Taylor 96-14 last Friday night to improve to 6-2 on the season. The game was not competitive.
The Commodores scored 52 points in the first quarter. They led 89-6 at halftime. There was no mercy rule.
While the second half was played with a running clock, it was played in full. The Titans refused to quit. Should they have?
An online debate has been sparked by the blowout. There are arguments to be made on both sides.
Maury annihilated Lake Taylor.
These two high school football teams compete in Virginia’s Eastern Division with Maury being a member of 5A and Lake Taylor playing at 3A. Lake Taylor entered at 4-4 and sixth in the league standings. Maury was 5-2 and in first place.
The rivals are separated by less than 10 miles. The Titans took the 20-minute drive west to face the Commodores last week. Things got ugly quick.
Google Maps
A map of Norfolk, Virginia.
Maury led 52-0 at the end of the first quarter. The score was 89-6 at halftime. Maury dominated the matchup. Lake Taylor had no answers on offense or defense.
Half: Maury 89, Lake Taylor 6 https://t.co/0KoHpr7QIu
— SuperEricRogers (@SuperEricRogers) October 24, 2026
No mercy rule was called despite the 83-point first half advantage. According to sportswriter Jim McGrath, there is no official language in the rulebook that forces the losing team to forfeit. Both sides, however, can agree to stop the competition.
Lake Taylor opted not to. A running clock was utilized, which the Titans exploited to prevent the Commodores from topping the 100-point mark.
When the final whistle blew, Maury led 96-14.
@jfmcgrath @sdearthvp @PilotSportsNow Where was the mercy rule 🤣🤣🤣🤦🏾♂️
— Jim Jim (@jimmiealex96) October 24, 2026
Should there be a mercy rule?
There are arguments to be made on each side. It’s something seen in other sports like baseball. Even the NCAA has a run rule that ends the game if a team goes up 10 runs in the seventh inning or later.
There is no mercy rule in Virginia high school football. Should there be?
Pros of having a mercy rule include player safety and operational efficiency. Many schools across the country have cancelled games for health concerns. Lake Taylor could’ve done the same for the second half. Sportsmanship can also come into play.
@jimmiealex96 @sdearthvp @PilotSportsNow The running clock is the closest thing, unless both teams agree to stop. Lake Taylor would not stop; in fact, they were talking smack after scoring in the last minute to get to 14. Carried over to after the game.
— Jim McGrath (@jfmcgrath) October 24, 2026
Lake Taylor chose not to quit despite trailing by 12 touchdowns in the first half. The coaching staff valued the playing time and experience. And if any positives can be taken away from the outing, it’s that the Titans continued to fight.
They actually outscored the Commodores in the second half, 8-7. They scored a touchdown on their final possession. Maybe it can create some momentum.
Lake Taylor refused to pack it in during the blowout loss. Was it the right call? That depends on who you ask.