
Via iStockphoto / @hellqueencocktails TikTok
What is a bartender supposed to do when they've made the drink perfectly, but the customer doesn't like it? Here's the controversial fix.
Have you ever gone to a bar with a fancy cocktail menu, ordered a drink, then taken one sip and been immediately disgusted?
According to bartender and TikTok user Elissa Dunn (@hellqueencocktails), you’re not alone. In a video with over 73,000 views, she shares that this is a common issue that bartenders have—and one that every bartender handles differently.
From the bartender’s perspective, here’s how it goes: A customer orders a drink. The bartender makes that drink exactly as described on the menu and according to the bar’s recipe. The customer takes a sip—and decides they don’t like it.
So, if you’re a bartender, what are you supposed to do in that situation?
For Dunn, the answer is simple: Make them a new drink, and give them their original drink for free.
“Even if they say, ‘I’m happy to pay for it,’ I will still take it off their bill,” she explains. “I will take it away from them, usually, and make them something else.”
“The second one will be the drink that they have to pay for,” she adds.
It’s A Controversial Stance
According to Dunn, this is not necessarily standard industry practice.
“I know a lot of people are like, ‘No. If I made it correctly and you don’t like it, that’s on you,’” Dunn states.
Still, she says that, in her video, “Margins are not more important than hospitality.”
“If someone doesn’t like their drink, I want them to tell me that they don’t like their drink,” she shares. “Even if I’ve made it absolutely exactly how it’s supposed to come, I want them to enjoy the drink that they are drinking.”
Dunn adds that complaints are often rare. This means that, if someone is complaining, it’s because “they truly don’t like it”—and giving them a new drink that they do like will dramatically improve their experience.
“Our job as hospitality professionals is…to provide hospitality. That will always be the first thing in my mind,” Dunn declares.
Is This Normal?
This is a common debate among bartenders.
On Reddit, the notion of “when to comp a drink” is a perennial debate.
In general, the consensus seems to be that if a customer orders a drink, takes a few sips, then doesn’t like it, the bartender should take the drink back and comp it. From there, they can discuss potential replacements with the customer.
“If it’s a cocktail off our slightly esoteric menu or a bartender’s choice thing and they don’t love it? Absolutely,” writes one user about drink comping. “If I see someone hardly touching their drink, I ask if they don’t care for it and offer to swap it even if it’s busy af.”
“See if you can figure out whether something may have gone wrong with prep, or if they just don’t like it,” advises another. “If something may have gone wrong, remake it. Ask if it’s better. If it’s better, brilliant.”
This same user then says that, if the drink was prepared properly and the customer has only taken a few sips, a bartender can toss the drink and make them a new one.
What If They’ve Already Finished The Drink?
All that said, if the customer has already consumed a substantial amount, the same user provides several alternative remedies.
“If they tell you after they finished it, say ‘well let’s make sure your next round is something you like’ and troubleshoot a bit. If they tell you and they’ve already had most of it, make them a half-size replacement,” the user states. “They’re not going to get something free by saying they don’t like it. Some people try that.”
While Dunn’s concerns about margins are valid, they will likely be inconsequential for a single drink replacement. The average bar’s gross profit margin—meaning the cost of ingredients compared to the cost of the drink itself—is typically between 70 and 80%.
This means that a bartender can remake a few drinks over the course of a busy night and only leave a minimal negative impact on the bar’s bottom line.
At the end of the day, a bartender must simply balance costs and customer experience. If you, as a customer, don’t like your drink, you should feel free to tell the bartender. Worst case? They make you pay for the drink you ordered.
She Stands Behind Her Policy
In an email to BroBible, Dunn explained that “this is just a good policy more than a personal policy versus management policy.”
“In a perfect world, a guest would let you know that they’re not enjoying their drink within the first one or two sips, so it’s on the bartender to kind of judge if they have almost completely consumed their drink, if they want to have the same practice or have a different approach,” she explains.
Concerning whether there’s a possibility that someone will try to take advantage of such a policy, Dunn says it happens, though it’s uncommon.
“There are definitely people who will try to take advantage of good hospitality,” she shares. “I wouldn’t say that it’s most people, so it’s on bartenders and based on their experience to judge the interaction and how to properly navigate that if they do think that someone is trying to take advantage.”
Sometimes, This Policy Depends On The Drink Itself
“It really depends on the expense of the cocktail and the ingredients that are going into it—if it’s a particularly high-priced spirit, for instance, that’s high-priced, out of the norm. We might take a different approach to immediately replacing a drink,” she writes. “And I think it can also go for non-spirit-based ingredients that [are] maybe not as expensive but harder to procure, so we might not have as many in stock or only have a particular amount for a specific amount of cocktails.”
Still, she says such policies are beneficial for businesses.
“Hospitality is always gonna have tangible benefits, especially in this day and age where good hospitality is harder and harder to find,” she concludes. “For the amount of money that it’s gonna cost for someone to spill the average drink, you’re going to see that money come back to you three times as much with repeat customers when they know that you are willing to go that extra mile for them and give them truly good hospitality.”
BroBible reached out to Dunn via email and website contact form.