Woman’s Date Orders Weller Antique. Then She Forces The Bartender To Serve Him Pappy Instead Of ‘Poor Person’s Drink’: ‘I Cannot Be Seen With Him’

glass of alcohol (l) bartender shares couple experience (c) man and woman on a bar date (r)

Via iStockphoto / @misssamanthab TikTok

A bartender says a woman was apoplectic after her date ordered this popular bourbon. What did she insist he order instead?


A bartender says that a woman made her date order an expensive shot of bourbon. What he did next shocked her.

In a video with over 47,000 views, TikTok user Samantha (@misssamanthab) recounts an experience she had while bartending.

According to Samantha, a man and a woman were sitting at the bar on a date. After the man ordered bourbon—specifically, W.L. Weller Antique 107—the woman quickly jumped in to change his order.

“‘You know, that’s a poor person’s drink,’” Samantha recalls the woman saying. “She looks at me. She goes, ‘Go ahead and pour him some Pappy. I will not be seen with somebody ordering alcohol made for poor people.’”

“Pappy” refers to a bourbon called Pappy Van Winkle.

Once Samantha poured the drink, the man “took it like a shot.” This apparently upset the woman, who demanded she pour another glass of Pappy.

Things Take A Turn

At some point, the man excused himself to go to the bathroom. The woman apparently took this as an opportunity to vent.

“I will not be seen with somebody who cannot afford the good things in life. It’s just not happening,” the woman allegedly said.

At some point, the woman realized that she and this man were fundamentally incompatible. As a result, she decided to tab out while the man was in the bathroom.

The problem? The man wasn’t actually in the bathroom—and had, in fact, already left.

“She’s like, ‘What? Are you kidding me? He stood me up, and he’s leaving—and I am a catch. How do people not understand that? I am a catch, and I am so financially secure, and he’s gonna leave me. Me! Absolutely not,’” Samantha recalls.

According to Samantha, this woman was a regular at the bar and would frequently bring dates—which were “a train wreck every single time.”

“Also, I don’t like Pappy,” Samantha adds. “Weller Antique is [expletive] phenomenal… To say it’s a poor person’s drink? Y’all are crazy.”

What Is ‘Pappy?’

Pappy Van Winkle, known simply as “Pappy” among bourbon enthusiasts, is a wheated Kentucky straight bourbon that is known for both its flavor and its rarity.

While the whiskey itself is critically acclaimed—VinePair reports that the 20-year-old expression received a near-perfect score of 99 out of 100 from the Beverage Testing Institute in 1996—it is also incredibly expensive.

Pappy Van Winkle is released in incredibly limited quantities. Add in high demand, and it’s not uncommon to see bottles on the secondary market for anywhere from $1,000 to more than $5,000.

There’s no doubt that Pappy is beloved. Whether it’s worth the price tag, however, is a different question.

W.L. Weller Antique 107, the other bourbon mentioned by Samantha, also enjoys critical praise. As reported by Food&Wine, the bourbon won the top prize at the 2025 London Spirits Competition, scoring 99 out of 100 possible points.

Apart from the difference in flavor, there’s a considerable difference in price. W.L. Weller Antique 107 can frequently be found for less than $100, while a bottle of Pappy, no matter the age, is sure to make a much more notable dent in your paycheck.

Viewers Defend The Man’s Choice

In the comments section, users offered their thoughts on Samantha’s story.

Some questioned whether anyone could even tell the difference between a cheap and an expensive drink after someone pours it.

“Once it’s in the glass, who can tell the difference?” asked a user.

Others questioned the woman’s allegiance to Pappy.

“Weller is better than Pappy 100%,” declared a commenter.

Further users noted that a high price tag doesn’t always denote quality.

“My fiancé used to work at an upscale restaurant and the owner’s wife was the wine expert,” recounted a viewer. “They would have rich doctors come in and ask for the most expensive wine and she would often ask, ‘Do you want the most expensive wine or the best wine?’”

That said, some claimed the woman may have just made a mistake.

“Is she confusing Weller with well?” asked a user. “Well” alcohol is typically low-cost and used for mixed drinks or cheap shots.

BroBible reached out to Samantha via Instagram and TikTok comment.