Best Gifts For Buffalo Bills Fans That Aren’t Season Tickets

When holiday shopping for the Bills Mafia members in your family, you need a gift that matches their energy. While you can’t go wrong with another plastic table, perhaps you’re looking for something that’ll last longer than just the next tailgate.

Whether they’ve started supporting the team through the Josh Allen era or since that particularly rough patch in the early 90s, they’re sure to appreciate these Buffalo Bills-themed holiday gifts.

From brand new Stefon Diggs or Von Miller jerseys to an endless selection of unique, affordable, and versatile team gear, we’ve rounded up all the best holiday gifts for the die-hard Bills fans in your life.

Shop below for the best team apparel from Fanatics, one-of-a-kind Bills Mafia gifts from Etsy, or plenty more of the best gifts for the Buffalo Bills fans in your life.

Bills Team Apparel


Bills Jerseys

You simply can’t go wrong with a brand new team jersey this holiday season. It’s always a classic gift and exactly what every die-hard Bills fan needs to fit in on game day. Fanatics offers jerseys for just about every player, including the fan favorites of Josh Allen, Stefon Diggs, and Von Miller.

Shop Bills Jerseys here via Fanatics



Hoodies - gifts for bills fans

You know the cold weather isn’t stopping Bills Mafia from going all out, so a Bills team hoodie is the perfect gift to keep them warm on game day. From military-inspired designs to throwback styles, Fanatics has more than enough hoodies to fit everyone’s preference.

Shop Bills Hoodies here Via Fanatics



Bills Shirts

For a more affordable option when it comes to team apparel, Fanatics has all the tees and long sleeves you could ask for. It’s the best way avid Buffalo Bills fans can display their loyalties even when it isn’t game day.

Shop Bills Shirts here Via Fanatics



Hats - gifts for bills fans

For the Bills Mafia members that want to show off their fandom wherever they go, Bills team hats are hard to beat. It’s the perfect finishing touch to any casual outfit no matter what the season is. Fanatics has you covered whether they like rocking snapbacks, beanies, or a multitude of other fits.

Shop Bills hats here via Fanatics


Team Gear Gifts For Bills Fans

Tervis Cups

Bills Tervis Cups

For those in Bills Mafia that already have all the team apparel they need, Bills-themed tumblers, can coolers, and water bottles from Tervis do just the trick this holiday season. Tervis offers high-performance and quality designs across a wide range of insulated drinkware.

Shop Bills Cups here via Tervis



Bills Gifts 2022 - Bills Coolers

Coolers are the perfect gift to ensure everyone is stocked up on drinks wherever the game day celebrations are. It’s a gift you can be certain that Bills Mafia will appreciate. They’re easy to carry and hold 8-20 cans depending on the design you select.

Shop Bills Coolers here via Amazon



Bills Backpacks

Buffalo Bills backpacks are an excellent choice for the fans that are always on the go, but still want to show their support for the squad. It’s an amazing gift they can take to school, work, the gym, or even on vacation.

Shop Bills Backpacks here via Amazon



Bills Gifts 2022 - Bills Blankets

We all know how cold it can get up in Buffalo, so a Bills blanket just makes sense as a holiday gift. They’re ultra-cozy and super-soft with phenomenal designs for one of the best gifts for all Buffalo Bills fans.

Shop Bills Blankets here via Amazon


Cheaper Bills Gifts From Fanatics

Gifts Under $10

Bills Gifts Under $10

In search of Bills-themed holiday stocking stuffers? Fanatics offers a wide selection of affordable gifts under $10, including outstanding prints, ornaments, drinkware, and so much more.

Shop Gifts Under $10 here


Gifts Under $20

Gifts Under $20 - gifts for bills fans

From affordable apparel to more stocking stuffers to actual stockings, Fanatics offers a diverse range of gifts under $20. It’s the ideal place to find the best gifts for Buffalo Bills fans without making a serious dent in your wallet.

Shop Gifts Under $20 here


Unique Bills Gifts From Etsy

Buffalo Bills LED Neon Sign

Bills Neon Sign

Whether it’s the man cave, garage, game room, or even bedroom, this Buffalo Bills LED neon sign knows how to bring a touch of flair. Plus, it’s available in 6 sizes with over 25 lighting settings for a unique gift that Bills superfans will love.

Shop Bills LED Neon Signs here


Bills Mafia Yard Sign

Bills Mafia Yard Sign - gifts for bills fans

For the proud Bills Mafia members, these yard signs are an excellent way to show their allegiance year-round. The signs are durable and resist fading, water, and stains for a gift that can withstand the Buffalo elements.

Shop Bills Mafia Yard Signs here


Bills Mafia Flag

Bills Mafia Flag

What better way for them to fly their colors than with the classic gift of a Bills Mafia flag! Whether hung up at home or by a tailgate, it’s a reliable choice this holiday season.

Shop Bills Mafia flags here


More Gifts For Bills Fans From Etsy

Gifts from Etsy - gifts for bills fans

If you think the die-hard Bills fan in your family already has it all, think again. Etsy offers countless Bills-themed holiday gifts that are truly unique. From vintage apparel to handmade signs to thoughtful coasters, there’s bound to be a gift that will enhance their collection.

Shop Etsy Bills Gifts here