O.J. Simpson’s Former Houseguest Kato Kaelin Recalls Strange Behavior On Night Of The Double Murders

Kato-Kaelin-reviews-transcripts-with-defense-attorney-Robert-Shapiro
Getty Image

More than 32 years after Nicole Brown Simpson and Ron Goldman were murdered, O.J. Simpson’s former houseguest Kato Kaelin is still questioning several strange things the former NFL star did that night.

“I question myself all the time,” Kaelin, 67, recently told Decider.

Kato Kaelin, who lived in a guesthouse on O.J. Simpson’s property in 1994, recalled five unusual interactions with to Pro Football Hall of Famer on June 12, 1994, during an interview about Peacock’s new documentary, O.J.’s Accomplice.

“I think O.J. is 100 percent guilty,” Kaelin said, adding, “I really think he was a sociopath.”

Kato Kaelin Recalls O.J. Simpson’s Strange Behavior On Night Of Murders

The first thing Kato Kaelin found unusual was O.J. Simpson’s unexpected appearance that night.

“[Simpson] coming to my bungalow door, which he [had] never done,” Kaelin recalled.

O.J. Simpson then strangely asked Kaelin if he could break a $100 bill.

When Simpson mentioned getting something to eat, Kaelin asked if he could go with him. According to Kato, O.J. responded with a “long pause.”

Looking back, Kaelin believes he “ruined his timeline” by asking to come along.

The two eventually went to McDonald’s sometime between approximately 9 and 9:45 p.m.

“Definitely he was in this mood. He was not very talkative in the car…he was silent,” Kaelin recalled. “I can’t get into someone’s mind, but there was something 100 percent on his mind.”

Kato-Kaelin-testifies-in-the-OJ-Simpson-trial
Getty Image

When they returned, Kaelin expected them to eat together.

Instead, O.J. Simpson “just stood there.”

Investigators estimated the murders occurred between approximately 10:15 and 10:45 p.m.

O.J. Simpson Documentary Raises New Questions About Possible Accomplices

The documentary examines whether Simpson received help from people like A.C. Cowlings, Charlie Ehrlich, or Joseph “Joey” Ippolito. Despite the theories presented in O.J.’s Accomplice, Kato Kaelin believes “O.J. acted alone.”

In one particularly revealing moment, O.J. Simpson associate Charlie Ehrlich claimed during a hot-mic conversation that Ippolito, a former drug smuggler, admitted involvement in the murders.

OJ-Simpson-talks-to-Francis-Bailey-Jr-during-trial
VJ Lovero-Imagn Images

Meanwhile, recently unsealed court documents raised additional questions about a possible accomplice. Former FBI profiler Jim Clemente has also argued that evidence from Ron Goldman’s injuries suggested two attackers.

However, none of those accomplice allegations have ever been proven true.

O.J. Simpson was acquitted of both murders in 1995 but found liable in a 1997 civil trial. He died in 2024 owing millions to the Goldman family and without ever having found the “true” murderer, as he had long promised.

Douglas Charles headshot avatar BroBible
Douglas Charles is a Senior Editor for BroBible with two decades of expertise writing about sports, science, and pop culture with a particular focus on the weird news and events that capture the internet's attention. He is a graduate from the University of Iowa.
Want more news like this? Add BroBible as a preferred source on Google!
Preferred sources are prioritized in Top Stories, ensuring you never miss any of our editorial team's hard work.
Google News Add as preferred source on Google