Wondering Why Astros Players Weren’t Punished By MLB? They Reportedly ‘Didn’t Know They Were In The Wrong’

Astros Players Not Punished Because They Were Given Immunity Report

Getty Image

Many people, including several players, were not satisfied with the punishment handed down to the Houston Astros franchise by Major League Baseball.

Most of them felt that MLB suspending Astros general manager Jeff Luhnow and manager AJ Hinch for one year, fining the team $5 million, and taking away Houston’s first and second-round picks in the 2020 and 2021 drafts was a small price to pay for appearing in the past two World Series, winning one. Especially considering MLB commissioner Rob Manfred stated that the Astros illegally stole signs from opponents during the 2017 season – year they won the World Series.

Many also wondered why, if it was the players on the Astros who participated and benefitted during games from the sign-stealing, why weren’t any of them punished?

Basically, all the players on the 2017 World Series roster get to keep their rings and all they have to do, IF they happen to still be on the Astros’ roster when spring training starts up in February is apologize.

Whether they follow through with any apologies remains to be seen, and seems unlikely, as the MLBPA may put a kibosh on even that small mea culpa.

The reason being reported for why Astros players did not receive any punishment from MLB is so MLB it hurts.

According to the Wall Street Journal, it’s because Manfred and MLB believed that if they did punish players they would end up losing any grievance hearings so instead they just gave the players immunity in exchange for their testimonies.

The main reason MLB felt it would lose any grievance hearings is because the Astros’ front office very conveniently failed to pass on Manfred’s 2017 sign-stealing memo to its players.

Embed from Getty Images

Manfred said that despite receiving those memos, Luhnow never forwarded them to or addressed their contents with the players and field staff, nor did he “confirm that the players and field staff were in compliance with MLB rules and the memoranda.” Through a spokesman, Luhnow declined to comment.

This was an important fact for MLB if it had wanted to try to discipline players. Penalties would have been met with grievances by the MLBPA — grievances that the league believes it would have lost, people familiar with the matter said.

After all, Manfred said, Hinch knew the sign-stealing was going on and didn’t stop it. Bench coach Alex Cora was an active participant in the plots. So was outfielder Carlos Beltrán, a respected veteran. Therefore, the union could have successfully argued in a grievance hearing that the players didn’t know they were in the wrong, since their superiors never directly informed them and even appeared to condone their behavior. (Cora and Beltrán both lost their jobs last week as the manager of the Red Sox and New York Mets, respectively.)

Once again, news surrounding how this whole debacle was handled by MLB and the Astros organization is not sitting well with fans and players.

Former A’s Teammate Says Mike Fiers Told MLB Astros Began Cheating In 2014, Continued Into 2019
1993 Cy Young Winner Jack McDowell Says Tony LaRussa Stole Signs Using A Camera With The White Sox In The 1980s
ESPN’s Jessica Mendoza Is Getting Dragged For Her Horrible Take That Mike Fiers Shouldn’t Have Outed The Astros
Pete Rose Goes On Rant About Why The Astros’ Cheating Is Way Worse Than Him Betting On Baseball Games
Mike Clevinger Puts Astros Pitcher Lance McCullers In A Body Bag After He Tries To Clap Back About Cheating

Doug avatar
Before settling down at BroBible, Douglas Charles, a graduate of the University of Iowa (Go Hawks), owned and operated a wide assortment of websites. He is also one of the few White Sox fans out there and thinks Michael Jordan is, hands down, the GOAT.